Cool Ranch Doritos, the snack the students' complaint says an AI gun detector flagged as a firearm. Illustrative photo from 2019. Image: Famartin / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped

Four teenagers who were handcuffed at gunpoint outside their Maryland high school, because an AI camera mistook a bag of Doritos for a gun, are suing the company behind the system, their school district and the police. Their complaint, filed on Tuesday in the Circuit Court for Baltimore County, says the alert had already been cancelled before officers were sent.

A bag of Cool Ranch Doritos

On the evening of October 20, 2025, Taki Allen, Yui-Osa Ogbeide, Devon Thompson Jr. and Keith Winfield III were waiting outside Kenwood High School in Baltimore County for a lift home after football practice. Taki was eating a bag of Cool Ranch Doritos his coach had given him, the complaint says.

Omnilert Gun Detect, an AI system that scans school security cameras for firearms, flagged the bag as a gun with 90% confidence. Omnilert's human reviewers passed it on, the suit says, texting a photo of Taki and the bag to at least 15 school and police staff.

The district has run the system in all 165 of its schools since 2024, on more than 7,000 cameras. The complaint cites Maryland's Office of the Inspector General for Education as finding that fewer than 1% of the alerts sent to the district over two years needed police involvement.

Cancelled, then sent anyway

Within about two minutes, the district's head of school safety, Eric Knox, a safety manager and a police sergeant saw a chip bag and cancelled the alert, the complaint says. A second text told everyone.

The suit says principal Kate Smith never looked at the cancellation. More than ten minutes later she opened the original alert, took a screenshot of Taki and sent it to the school resource officer on his personal phone. She texted colleagues: "Omni alert is working. Kid standing on my patio right now. Looks like one of mine and looks like he's armed." The officer passed the screenshot to the local precinct, and at 7:21pm police were dispatched to a "report of a suspicious person with a weapon".

At least six patrol cars arrived, according to the complaint. Officers, several with guns drawn, ordered the four boys to their knees on the concrete, then handcuffed and searched them. They found nothing. Asked by Devon why he was held, one officer allegedly replied: "guilty by association if you want to say that."

"AI is not the best"

Officers then matched the screenshot to empty Doritos bags in a nearby bin, the suit says. One told the students "AI's not the best". Another, leaving, muttered about "stupid AI cameras". The supervising corporal allegedly thanked them for not running away, adding that it "would have been a real problem."

Keith's mother, Freida Winfield, was on her way to collect the boys. She said in the Lawyers' Committee's announcement:

The police told my son this could have been a real problem. No child in Baltimore County should face this kind of danger while waiting outside his own school for a ride home from his mother.

Freida Winfield, Keith Winfield III's mother

The suit quotes Omnilert's marketing promise of "Near-Zero False Positives", and says the company defended the system afterwards as having "functioned as intended". Maryland's Inspector General for Education, Richard Henry, put the incident down to "human error" last December, Maryland Matters reports.

What the students want

The four students, all Black, are represented by the Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, Willkie Farr & Gallagher and Engel Law Group. They claim unlawful search and seizure under the US Constitution and Maryland's Declaration of Rights, false arrest, negligence and gross negligence. Defendants include Omnilert, the county, the school board, Knox, Smith and eight officers.

They want compensatory and punitive damages set by a jury, and a court order barring the district and county from using Omnilert, or any similar AI gun detector, until proper checks, cancellation procedures and training are in place. They also want police to stop detaining students just for standing near someone an alert flags.

These students were failed not only by a technology that is prone to false alerts, but also by the very adults meant to keep them safe when we send them to school.

Damon Hewitt, president, Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law

An Omnilert spokesperson told Maryland Matters the company "cannot comment on lawsuits", and county police and school officials declined to comment on pending litigation. Police AI is under scrutiny elsewhere too, from tools that flag "suspicious" road trips.

Why it matters

Schools across the US are buying AI weapon detectors on the promise that a human checks every alert. This case says the humans did catch the mistake, and armed police still came. A ruling could set out who carries the blame when an AI alert is wrong.

Sources: Allen v. Omnilert complaint (Circuit Court for Baltimore County); Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law; Maryland Matters

Latest Policy & Safety news

More Policy & Safety news