
Osgoode Hall in Toronto, home of the Court of Appeal for Ontario, photographed in May 2012. Image: Terry Ozon / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0, cropped
OpenAI has lost its bid to move Canada's biggest newspaper lawsuit to a US court. In a unanimous ruling on Friday, the Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed its appeal, so the copyright case brought by the Toronto Star, The Globe and Mail, Postmedia, The Canadian Press and CBC/Radio-Canada over ChatGPT will be heard in Ontario, under Canadian law.
What the court decided
Justice B.W. Miller wrote the decision, with Justices Lise Favreau and Moiz Rahman agreeing. It upholds Justice Jessica Kimmel's November 7, 2025 ruling in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, which found that Ontario had jurisdiction over six OpenAI companies and dropped four others from the case. It ordered OpenAI to pay the publishers C$100,000 in costs agreed by the two sides.
The ruling settles where the case is heard, not whether OpenAI broke the law. The publishers, who sued in November 2024, say OpenAI crawled and scraped their journalism to train and run the models behind ChatGPT, in breach of Canada's Copyright Act and their websites' terms of use, and that it was unjustly enriched as a result. None of that has been tested at trial.
No office in Ontario, but doing business there
OpenAI's companies are incorporated in Delaware and argued that they had no physical presence in Ontario. Justice Miller wrote that "the authorities cited in support of a proposition that physical presence is required do not assist", and that the bar for a court to take on a foreign company is lower. The motion judge had found that OpenAI companies used web crawlers to gather data located in Ontario, made contractual arrangements there, used training data from Ontario users, advertised there and licensed their tools to customers in the province.
The court also accepted that some of the alleged copying is tied to Ontario: material sent "from or through Canada (through scraping or training)", or sent back to users in Canada through ChatGPT. And it agreed that the publishers' website terms of use, so-called "browse wrap" agreements, could be contracts made in Ontario that OpenAI's crawlers breached. Any one of those links would have been enough; the court found three.
US and Canadian courts can disagree
OpenAI's fallback was that the US was clearly the better place for the case. Its training cannot be split cleanly into Canadian and American parts, it argued, so two courts could reach inconsistent findings. The appeal court backed the motion judge's answer, which it quoted:
The consideration under this factor is whether different courts may reach conflicting decisions in respect of the particular facts of this case, not whether courts in the United States and Canada may apply their respective jurisprudence to reach different conclusions on novel legal issues.
Justice Jessica Kimmel, Ontario Superior Court of Justice
That matters because US courts are still arguing over whether AI training is fair use, a broad, flexible US defence; one US appeals court rejected it for an AI legal research tool in September, and OpenAI faces a growing pile of US suits, including USA Today's $250 million claim. Canada's version, fair dealing, is narrower and covers only listed purposes such as research, private study, education, parody, satire, criticism and news reporting. The motion judge also noted that OpenAI filed no evidence that a Canadian judgment would conflict with US law and be hard to enforce.
What it means for Anthropic
Four of the same publishers, without CBC/Radio-Canada, sued Anthropic in the Ontario Superior Court on October 6, making similar claims about Claude, including that its crawlers ignored their terms of use. That suit also names Anthropic's Canadian subsidiary. Friday's ruling gives Ontario's lower courts appeal-court authority that a US AI company with no office in the province can be sued there for scraping Ontario websites, and that the chance of a different US result is no reason to send a case south.
OpenAI can still argue that most of its copying happened outside Canada, beyond the Copyright Act's reach, which the motion judge said could narrow the claims at trial. But the appeal court said such points go to the merits, and OpenAI cannot raise them without accepting the Ontario court's jurisdiction. OpenAI can ask the Supreme Court of Canada for leave to appeal within 60 days. It hasn't commented on the ruling.
Why it matters
This is the first Canadian case over training generative AI on copyrighted work, and it will now be fought under Canadian law, where the fair dealing defence is narrower than US fair use. For any AI company that scrapes the Canadian web, Ontario's top court has made clear that the answer in a US courtroom will not settle the question in Canada.
Sources: Court of Appeal for Ontario, Toronto Star Newspapers Limited v. OpenAI, Inc., 2026 ONCA 814; The Canadian Press


